Time-Resolving Black Holes from LEO
Ref Bari, Brown University
"Metrics and Motivations for Earth–Space VLBI: Time-resolving Sgr A* with the Event Horizon Telescope" Palumbo et. al. ApJ 2019
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
"Imaging the event horizon of M87* from space on different timescales" Shlentsova et. al. ApJ 2024
Black Hole
VLBI
LEO
Black Hole
VLBI
LEO
Schwarzschild Black Hole
Very Long Baseline Interferometry
Low-Earth Orbit
Black Hole
VLBI
LEO
Physics MS, Brown
Analysis of Binary Black Holes via Neural Networks (under Prof. Brendan Keith, Brown)
Funded under NSF Neural DynAMO Grant
“Nitrogen Outgassing from Water Worlds” (R.Bari et. al., under review, The Astrophysical Journal 2025)
“Reflection from Relativistic Light Sails” (R. Bari, The Astronomical Journal 2024)
“Simulating the Action Principle in Optics” (R. Bari, The Physics Teacher 2023)
Spin Qubit CNN Researcher at the Meriles Condensed Matter Lab
“A Path Integral Derivation of Hawking Radiation” (MS Thesis)
Physics MS, Brown
Analysis of Binary Black Holes via Neural Networks (Prof. Brendan Keith, Brown)
Brown Space Engineering
Spaceflight Heritage
EQUiSat
SBUDNIC
PVDX
Spaceflight Heritage
SBUDNIC
PVDX
EQUiSat
Spaceflight Heritage
SBUDNIC
PVDX
EQUiSat
Pathfinder
Pathfinder
M87
Sgr A*
M87
Sgr A*
Event Horizon Telescope
(2019)
Event Horizon Telescope (EHT)
Event Horizon Telescope
(2019)
Event Horizon Telescope (EHT)
Spaceflight Heritage
EQUiSat
SBUDNIC
PVDX
Spaceflight Heritage
SBUDNIC
PVDX
EQUiSat
Pathfinder
Pathfinder
Imaging a Black Hole
"Metrics and Motivations for Earth–Space VLBI: Time-resolving Sgr A* with the Event Horizon Telescope" Palumbo et. al. ApJ 2019
Optical Terminals
RF Tracking Stations
VLBI Ground Stations
T-REX Data Center
Optical Terminals
RF Tracking Stations
VLBI Ground Stations
T-REX Data Center
Optical Terminals
RF Tracking Stations
VLBI Ground Stations
T-REX Data Center
Size
Weight
Power
Power
Cost
Aspera
Pandora
StarBurst
PUEO
(Galaxy Evolution via UV)
(Exoplanet Explorer)
(Neutron Stars via Gamma Rays)
(Particle Physics via High-Energy Neutrinos)
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
SEFD
USO
Data
Orbit
Partner Satellite to BHEX
Stand-alone Satellite
Pathfinder Mission
Partner Satellite to BHEX
Stand-alone Satellite
Pathfinder Mission
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Partner Satellite to BHEX
Stand-alone Satellite
Pathfinder Mission
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Partner Satellite to BHEX
Stand-alone Satellite
Pathfinder Mission
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Pathfinder Mission
Partner Satellite to BHEX
Stand-alone Satellite
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Survey of >25 AGN+BH Targets @86 GHz
Enable Population Modeling of SMBHs
Enable real-time imaging of dynamical accretion disk around Sgr A*
Enable multi-messenger gravitational astronomy w/ LIGO + LISA
Partner Satellite to BHEX
Stand-alone Satellite
Pathfinder Mission
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Supplement (u,v) coverage at 86 GHz
Enable parameter estimation of Sgr A*/M87
Achieve Space-Space VLBI
Survey of >25 AGN+BH Targets @86 GHz
Enable Population Modeling of SMBHs
Enable real-time imaging of dynamical accretion disk around Sgr A*
Enable multi-messenger gravitational astronomy w/ LIGO + LISA
Enable low-cost Space-Ground & Space-Space VLBI
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Prospects of Detecting a Jet in Sagittarius A* with VLBI (Chavez et. al., ApJ 2024)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Metrics and Motivations for Earth–Space VLBI: Time-resolving Sgr A* with the Event Horizon Telescope (Palumbo et. al., ApJ 2019)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Metrics and Motivations for Earth–Space VLBI: Time-resolving Sgr A* with the Event Horizon Telescope (Palumbo et. al., ApJ 2019)
"Metrics and Motivations for Earth–Space VLBI: Time-resolving Sgr A* with the Event Horizon Telescope" Palumbo et. al. ApJ 2019
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Multifrequency Black Hole Imaging for the Next-generation Event Horizon Telescope (Chael et. al., 2023, ApJ)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution:
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Maximum data transmission rate (in bits per second); How fast can you send data from BHEX Mini to the earth?
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Power of Transmitted Signal: Strength of downlink signal in Watts (i.e., shouting louder to be heard further away!)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Transmitter Gain: How well-focused your signal is when it leaves the satellite
(i.e., shouting into a megaphone instead of into the wind)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Receiver Gain: How effectively the ground station collects and concentrates the incoming signal (i.e., ALMA's big dish listening to our incoming signal)
Received Power: How strong is the signal once it hits the ground receiver? (after traveling through empty space)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Receiver Gain: How effectively the ground station collects and concentrates the incoming signal (i.e., ALMA's big dish listening to our incoming signal)
Distance: How much distance did the signal travel through free space? (LEO vs. MEO!)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Receiver Gain: How effectively the ground station collects and concentrates the incoming signal (i.e., ALMA's big dish listening to our incoming signal)
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
30 min
60 min
90 min
24 hr
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Sub-milli arcsecond angular resolution
Dual short and long baseline lengths
Rapid coverage of (u,v) plane
Decreased signal loss from LEO
Decreased radiation environment in LEO vs. MEO
Decreased ISM scattering at LEO than MEO
Decreased ISM scattering at LEO than MEO
Orbit design for mitigating interstellar scattering effects in Earth-space VLBI observations of Sgr A* (Aditya Tamar, Ben Hudson, Daniel C.M. Palumbo, A&A, 2025)
Decreased ISM scattering at LEO than MEO
Intrinsic Gaussian Source
Decreased ISM scattering at LEO than MEO
ISM Scattering
Decreased ISM scattering at LEO than MEO
BHEX Mini Visibility Amplitude Advantage
Regardless of Source Flux Density!
Size
Weight
Power
Power
Cost
Size
Weight
Power
Power
Cost
Antenna
Receiver
Cryocooler
Cryocooler
HiPTC Heat Intercepted Pulse Tube Cooler
Solar Panels
Ultra-Stable Oscillator
Ultra-Stable Oscillator
Phase Error
Ultra-Stable Oscillator
Ultra-Stable Oscillator
Allan Deviation
ABRACON SMD OCXO
Digital Backend
Original Analog Radio Signal
Sample the Signal every Unit Interval
Nyquist-Shannon Sampling Theorem
Retain only the samples and record the sign of the voltage for each sample
Reconstruct the original signal
Jan 2025
Jan 2025
Jan 2025
Jan 2025
Feb 2025
Jan 2025
Feb 2025
Mar 2025
Rick Fleeter
Jan 2025
Feb 2025
Mar 2025
Apr 2025
Ben Hudson
Luke Anderson
Jan 2025
Feb 2025
Mar 2025
Apr 2025
May 2025
Jeffrey Olson
Jun 2025
Jul 2025
Todd Ely
Joseph Lazio
Eric Burt
Jan 2025
Feb 2025
Mar 2025
Apr 2025
May 2025
Jun 2025
Jul 2025
Feb 2025
Mar 2025
Apr 2025
May 2025
Jun 2025
Jul 2025
Aug 2025
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
BHEX Mini
Team
Advisors
Inner
circle
Inner
circle
Engineering
Leadership
Advisors
BHEX Mini
Team
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
Advisors
BHEX Mini
Team
Engineering
Leadership
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Advisors
BHEX Mini
Team
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
Advisors
BHEX Mini
Team
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
BHEX Mini
Team
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
Advisors
BHEX Mini
Team
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
Advisors
Inner
circle
Science
Leadership
Engineering
Leadership
Advisors
BHEX Mini
Team
🕒 Prospective Timeline
June
July
August
September
🕒 Prospective Timeline
June
July
August
September
🕒 Prospective Timeline
June
July
August
September
🕒 Prospective Timeline
June
July
Aug
September
🕒 Prospective Timeline
June
July
Aug
Sep
💰Funding Deadlines
June
💰Funding Deadlines
$5,000
July
💰Funding Deadlines
$5,000
$175,000
Aug
💰Funding Deadlines
$5,000
$175,000
>$4M
Sep
💰Funding Deadlines
$5,000
$175,000
>$4M
Oct
💰Funding Deadlines
$5,000
$175,000
>$4M
>$400,000